Tue 3rd November / 19:45 / Challenge Cup 26/27 / / away
Hamilton Academical vs Raith Rovers
Line Up
Report
Hamilton 1 – 1 Raith Rovers (5-3 on penalties)
Raith’s hopes of retaining the Challenge Cup were dashed on Tuesday evening after falling to a defeat via Penalties, following a 1-1 draw with Hamilton.
Hamilton earned an early lead before Raith equalised moments before halftime. A hard-fought second half followed, before a decisive penalty shootout advanced the hosts to the round of 16.
Dougie Imrie made about every change available to him after Raith’s 4-0 win in Arbroath four days prior. Jai Rowe, Callum Fordyce, Arron Lyall, Kyle Turner, and Anton Dowds were all put into the starting 11, whilst Luke Armstrong got the start in goal. Josh Rae, Jack Baird, Calum Adamson, Ross Millen, and Kai Montagu made up the five-man bench – a group that all started against Arbroath.
Hamilton got things underway and did well to quell some early Raith advances in the opening ten minutes or so.
The hosts wouldn’t take long in turning defence to attack, which saw Aaron Eadie put a cross into the Rovers box less than a minute after a Hamilton goal-kick. Eadie’s ball ultimately wasn’t dealt with and, after a parrying save from Armstrong, Hamilton would score with Dominic Shiels firing in the rebound from close range in the 11th minute.
Armstrong was called into action again in the 29th after a difficult deflection sent a looping ball towards goal. A strong one-handed save allowed Raith to clear for a corner, and a narrowly wayward header at the back post ultimately ended the danger.
Raith would level after a perfect long ball from Fordyce found a clean-through Scott Tiffoney. A heavy touch took Hamilton keeper Josh Lane out of the equation, which left Tiffoney to score into a near-empty net from the angle for a leveller in the 44th.
Both sides crafted some great chances to find a winner as the second half progressed. Hamilton were denied only by the post after Shield’s smartly dinked effort missed by the narrowest of margins, whilst close-range shots from Scott Brown and Paul Hanlon were both saved by Lane soon after.
The full-time whistle indicated a penalty shoot-out was up next, with extra time not utilised in the Challenge Cup.
Both sides converted their first two spot-kicks, before a great save from Lane put Tiffoney’s low strike onto the bar and away from goal.
Hamilton converted the rest of their attempts without issue, putting Raith out of the 2026/27 Challenge Cup in the round of 32.
Raith won’t have much time to dwell, though, with a return to Starks Park for a Fife Derby on the cards this Friday night.
Report by Hamish Rankine


























































